The mental patient throws the little lover of gas pitcher of liquefaction away and is broken and dies paralysedly in the high building

The mental patient throws the little lover of gas pitcher of liquefaction away and is broken and dies paralysedly in the high building
Last New Year's Day, liberate the intersection of tablet and the intersection of liquefaction and gas pitcher that fall down under Peace Hotel, afford to bungle one namely newly-married lover. Pan , people of crime, determine the department limits the schizophrenia patient of capacity. Court court of criminal sentence perpetual sentence, deprive of political rights to Pan all the life. Last 2 years passed by, this incident had the newest progress - -The dead and the intersection of wounded and relative lodge a complaint hotel and criminal once again, the total value of the civil claim exceeds 120 Wan Yuan. In the afternoon of yesterday, the court of Yuzhong District tried this case.
The incident is returned
Will it be will it be will it be 50 past 3 afternoon such as festival New Year's Day 2008, liberate the intersection of tablet and national the intersection of way and peace in front of the dispensary, liquefaction petroleum gas pitcher comes down from the Heaven, break a pair of lovers who plans to go to Chongqing gold shop to buy the wedding to give up upside down on the ground. The wife people ornament on a bridle dies on the spot; The husband Yao Ming broke away from the life dangerously after first aid of the army, left limbs were partial and paralysed, totally lose the ability of working, and severe intelligence defect, can't live independently.
After police get involved, arrest the suspect Pan quickly. Pan is the people of long-lived district, 30 years old. It in the intersection of thing and the intersection of person who take place and the intersection of Peace Hotel and overlooking room of upstairs, until prepared plank, pulley, rope, candle,etc. fit an organ in advance ' Have just made one and delayed time to fit actually) ,Hang two liquefaction gas pitchers of 5 kilograms outside the window with the rope, after blowing the rope after the candle is burnt, the gas pitcher just drops on the pavement downstairs of the hotel, injure the innocent.
22 days of April of 2008, the intermediate court of city five will try this case publicly. Pan accuses him of setting up the dangerous device to the procuratorial organ, causes the behavior of one death and one wound to have no objection. But he thinks one's own behavior is controlled by the E.T., the real murderer is an E.T., do not form the crime oneself.
The expert's conclusion to Pan of the mental hygiene centre of Chongqing is " Suffer from schizophrenia, it is to limit capacity people " .
Court sentence life imprisonment to Pan in the same day then, deprive political right for life, the charge is " L With the crime against public security of the dangerous method" .
After the pronouncement of the first instance, Pan puts forward appeal. In May of 2008, keep judging originally after the second instance of city Supreme Court.
The court debates fiercely
Injure in the square crime sides and all say the hotel should sustain economic losses the pharmaceuticals of higher level of the hotel claim that there is not responsibility
The intersection of the dead and father of people ornament on a bridle Luo Qing Luo come to claim, at the time of criminal justice originally, they determined the civil claim is handled as a separate case and prosecuted.
On September 25, 2008, they will sue medical Peace Hotel of Limited Company of Chongqing to the court of Yuzhong District. After Peace Hotel is prosecuted, apply to demand to add extra psychosis criminals for the defendant; The court did not find the criminal's legal representative until last week. Because Peace Hotel is the unit under medical Co., Ltd. of Chongqing, without independent legal personality, for this reason, the pharmaceuticals is added extra as the defendant in court too.
The victim is an agent : The hotel has not done duty
The wounded soldier Yao Ming's agent, mountain great lawyer Li of lawyer's office Chongqing pot claim, Pan holds the fake ID card to move in the hotel on the day when the case happened, demands to live in the room high, at the front of the floor. But the hotel lets it moved in . And Pan Zheng has implemented the crime and injured the innocent in the hotel room.
Li Hong claims, Pan lives in the hotel after stepping on some many times, the hotel has not checked and interfered, have just created the favorable offence condition for Pan . Meanwhile, there is not the hotel " L Forbidden to take flammable and explosive articles and enter the shop " R Warning,either go on this kind article check. Peace Hotel has not tried the security attention obligation in the rational range, has just led to the fact the tragedy takes place, so should bear compensation responsibility.
The lawyer that Luo Qing came has put forward the same reason too .
The amount of claim of request 30 over Wan, overth the intersection of damages and total value that MingBing Yao put forward up to 90 over yuan Wan.
Mental patient's father : The hotel has responsibility
Yesterday, Pan 's father appeared in court as its legal representative, he was before the reply, at first " Express the most sincere apology to the dead, wounded and family " . As to this accident, he claims it is totally the responsibility of the hotel.
Father Pan has put forward four reasons that the hotel should take on the responsibility .
The first, what his son held while moving in is fake ID card, but the hotel can not discern.
The second, his son demands to live in the high overlooking house on storey, the waiter thinks too his son is strange, why not cause looking out, why not check.
The third, sweep the room in successively two requirements of his son, the waiter obeyed. If waiters entered swept, the miserable case would not take place. His son requires " L Don't sweep the room " R Get thing take place, have time only for less than 10 minute during that time, waiter lose save best time taking place in tragedy.
Fourth, the ordinary persons all know the public occasion can not bring the gas pitcher, why will the hotel let guests bring into the gas pitcher.
Hotel and pharmaceuticals : We have no responsibility
The agent of Peace Hotel is called, any hotel is unable to verify guest's ID card true and false at present. Pan held the fake ID card at that time, the photo was Pan's.
Pan will it be will it be 6 morning January 1 50 live, enter, it is one day in accommodation time to register, arrive according to the regulation 2 days Did not calculate for one day until 12 o'clock . So, as guests have not checked out to propose when not sweeping the room, they have only opinion of respecting guests.
The hotel side also claims, after Pan moves in, successively left the hotel twice. While returning twice, are carrying the travel of a cowherd's cloth to wrap up. It is impossible for them to go to check guest's carry-on luggage; Unless guests are carrying the angry pot directly, they will not interfere.
So, hotel and pharmaceuticals agent all claim, this is the tragedy that a criminal makes all alone, having no relation with them, they have no responsibility, ask the court to reject and prosecute.
|